Payback's RESPONSE TO KERRI'S POSTING: This is surely the only case of "academic fraud" in the history of American education. Davidson could never have perpetrated "academic fraud" with her 1994 New Melville issue of AMERICAN LITERATURE ("We already have full-scale biographies of Melville"--this when no biographer had yet published on the basis of the great 1983 trove of family documents). Brodhead could never have perpetrated "academic fraud" in the New York TIMES on 23 June 2002 when he declared that only Hershel Parker alone in his "black hole" had ever imagined there was something Melville wrote called POEMS and tried to publish in 1860. There surely could be no "academic fraud" in writing a book called THE SCHOOL OF HAWTHORNE without taking a roll call to see who occupied the seats in the classroom. Oh no! "Academic fraud" has to be restricted to something momentous like deciding to teach a class out of the classroom as independent study. It could not consist of going into a classroom time after time while mouthing New Critical and Politically Correct idiocies. |
"That truth should be silent I had almost forgot"--Enobarbus in ANTONY AND CLEOPATRA, back in Rome after having been too long in Egypt.--------- Melville's PIERRE, Book 4, chapter 5: "Something ever comes of all persistent inquiry; we are not so continually curious for nothing."
Sunday, June 10, 2012
Unpunishable Academic Fraud-
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment