The Loyalists, Regarded with Political Correctness, and my Comment

What Happened To British Loyalists After The Revolutionary War?

By editor • 3 hours ago

• 

During the Revolutionary War, many loyalists were treated brutally --€” like the tarred and feathered man in this print. When the war wrapped up, loyalists often found they had to fend for themselves, or flee.

David Claypoole Johnston Library of Congress

Listen

Listening...

Originally published on July 4, 2015 6:09 pm

It's July Fourth weekend — a time that many Americans dedicate to celebrating democracy and the birth of the United States. But more than two centuries ago, when the Revolutionary War ended with an American victory, not everyone was celebrating.
It's estimated that between 15 and 20 percent of the population back then still remained loyal to the British Crown. Naturally, they weren't so thrilled by the climactic British surrender at the Battle of Yorktown in 1781, which effectively sealed the fate of King George's attempt to keep the colonists in line.
So what became of these loyalists who suddenly found themselves on the wrong side of history? To answer that question, NPR's Rachel Martin spoke with Maya Jasanoff, a professor of history at Harvard University.

---

Interview Highlights

On what it was like to be a British loyalist during the American revolution
There were definitely instances of people being beaten up on by gangs who would come to their house and harass them for being on the wrong side. It has to be said that some loyalists certainly were able to just kind of lie low and go about their business and try to not say too much about politics. But if you were living on the front lines of these advancing armies going back and forth across the colonies, it could be really a difficult choice and a difficult situation to be in.
On the lives of loyalists after the war
The fighting actually continued, in the backcountry of the South in particular. And it was in regions like that that loyalists still tried to fight for the empire that they believed in. ...
It's a part of the war that we tend to not think too much about or learn about in school. But there was a lot of bloodshed, and particularly in the South. And gangs of revolutionaries, gangs of loyalists, would attack each other, go to each other's plantations. In fact, some of the big battles in the South happened after the surrender at Yorktown.
So, what all of this means is that there was a climate of violence and a climate of fear for many loyalists. And it meant that when the peace negotiations were going on, they were really concerned about what kinds of protections they might have in the new United States. And during this period, many of them felt that the protections that the U.S. was offering were not promises that they could really get behind.
And so, when the British pulled out in city after city in the United States, up to tens of thousands of loyalists sometimes went with the retreating army to Britain and other parts of the British Empire. ... About half of the loyalists who left the United States ended up going north to Canada, settling in the province of Nova Scotia and also becoming pioneering settlers in the province of New Brunswick.
On how history books commemorate the loyalists
On the American side, of course, they're losers. And history is, as we know, written by the winners. So there's not much place for the loyalists — especially the loyalists who left — in standard American history.
But the British also have a kind of complicated relationship to the loyalists. And I think the reason is that the British have a complicated relationship to the Revolutionary War and to the United States, which is a place that they wanted to hold on to and failed to. And the loyalists were, at times, a very uneasy reminder of this defeat.

Copyright 2015 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript
RACHEL MARTIN, HOST:
We are heading into the 4th of July weekend, a time to celebrate freedom and democracy and these United States. But when the Revolutionary War ended in 1781, not everyone was celebrating. It is estimated that between 15 and 20 percent of the population back then were loyal to the British Crown and thus were not so thrilled when Cornwallis surrendered at Yorktown. What became of these loyalists who suddenly found themselves on the wrong side of history? To answer that question, we are joined by Maya Jasanoff. She's a professor of history at Harvard University.
Thanks so much for being with us.
MAYA JASANOFF: My pleasure, thanks.
MARTIN: First of all, what was it like to live as someone who was loyal to the British Crown during the American Revolution? I mean, is it something people were public about? Weren't you just considered a traitor, and tarred and feathered?
JASANOFF: Well, that's certainly the stereotype and there were definitely instances of people being beaten up on by gangs would come to their house and harass them for being on the wrong side. It has to be said that some loyalists certainly were able to just kind of lie low and go about their business and try to not say too much about politics. But if you were living on the front lines of these advancing armies going back and forth across the colonies, it could be really a difficult choice and a difficult situation to be in.
MARTIN: What about after the war? What happened to them?
JASANOFF: So the fighting actually continued, in the backcountry of the South in particular. And it was in regions like that that loyalists still tried to fight for the empire that they believed in.
MARTIN: Even after the war had officially come to a close?
JASANOFF: Yes, and it's a part of the war that we tend to not think too much about or learn about in school. But there was a lot of bloodshed, and particularly in the South. And gangs of revolutionaries, gangs of loyalists, would attack each other, go to each other's plantations. In fact, some of the big battles in the South happened after the surrender at Yorktown.
So what all of this means is that there was a climate of violence and a climate of fear for many loyalists. And it meant that when the peace negotiations were going on, they were really concerned about what kinds of protections they might have in the new United States. And during this period, many felt that the protections that the U.S. was offering were not promises that they could really get behind. And so when the British pulled out in city after city in the United States, up to tens of thousands of loyalists sometimes went with the retreating army to Britain and other parts of the British Empire.
MARTIN: Did many go to Canada?
JASANOFF: Yeah, so about half of the loyalists who left the United States ended up going north to Canada, settling in the province of Nova Scotia and also becoming pioneering settlers in the province of New Brunswick.
MARTIN: How do history books commemorate these people?
JASANOFF: You know, it's an interesting question. On the American side, of course, they're losers. And history is, as we know, written by the winners. So there's not much place for the loyalists - especially the loyalists who left - in standard American history. But the British also have a kind of complicated relationship to the loyalists. And I think the reason is that the British have a complicated relationship to the Revolutionary War and to the United States, which is a place that they wanted to hold on to and failed to. And the loyalists were, at times, a very uneasy reminder of this defeat.
MARTIN: Maya Jasanoff is a professor of history at Harvard University.
Thanks so much for talking with us.
JASANOFF: Thanks so much for having me. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

·        

Hershel Parker • a few seconds ago

My goodness, if you are going to talk about violence in the South after Yorktown you have to talk about the Tory Colonel David Fanning's murderous rampages in North Carolina in the early months of 1782, when he terrorized a big stretch of the state. Violence in the Carolinas was never one-sided. Many, many Patriot men were afraid to sleep in their houses when they were home, hoping that Tories would not burn their houses out from under women and children. They slept in the woods instead. In South Carolina in 1780-1781, in particular, Patriots were victims of marauders like Bloody Bill Cunningham. Please, do not get all weepy about some loyalists having to flee to Canada! Better, figure out how other Tory families lived on in their old lands or did what some of mine did. Tory Uncle John Pyle Jr. lost an eye and part of a hand at the Hacking Party early in 1781, but after the war he and around 8 of his Brasher in-law heads of families and his brother-in-law (by then) my Patriot GGGG Grandfather Ezekiel Henderson went off from Central NC to Greenville in western SC together, and settled. The Brashers got some land given to them, former Tories or not. How did this happen and how did they deal with their recent pasts? I don't know. Apparently Pyle was most ashamed or humiliated, for he went off to KY and IL, but as far as I know he was allowed to live unmolested. It is ignorant Political Correctness to bemoan our unkindness to Tories!